Friday, Aug. 22, 2014

Why breastfed babies are so smart

By Lois M. Collins, Deseret News National Edition

Published: Fri, March 14 8:00 p.m. MDT

 Breastfeeding helps babies in lots of ways, but it may not be the key to getting little guys on track to succeed in school. A BYU study shows cognitive development is revved up by reading to children and paying attention to their emotional cues.

Breastfeeding helps babies in lots of ways, but it may not be the key to getting little guys on track to succeed in school. A BYU study shows cognitive development is revved up by reading to children and paying attention to their emotional cues.


Breastfeeding helps babies in lots of ways, but it's not the key to getting little guys on track to succeed in school as some have suggested. A recent BYU study shows cognitive development is revved up by reading to babies starting around 9 months and by paying attention to their emotional cues.

Moms who breastfeed tend to do both those things, said the authors of the study, which is published in The Journal of Pediatrics.

"What we find is no advantage for early, early cognitive development," said Ben Gibbs, sociology professor at Brigham Young University and the study's lead author. "It is really a proxy for the kinds of mothers who breastfeed."

The study does not suggest that breastfeeding isn't valuable in other ways for babies, according to Gibbs and study co-author and fellow BYU professor Renata Forste.

Simply put, mothers who breastfeed are likely to be the type of parent who would read to a child every night and pay close attention to a child's emotional cues, he said.

They found that being attentive to a child's emotional cues and reading consistently with the child could make a difference of 2-3 months in brain development in children by age 4, when they are entering preschool. That is measured by math and reading readiness testing checks, they said.

"There is a positive relationship between predominant breastfeeding for three months or more and child reading skills, but this link is the result of cognitively supportive parenting behaviors and greater levels of education among women who predominantly breastfed," the study reported. "We found little-to-no relationship between infant feeding practices and the cognitive development of children with less-educated mothers. Instead, reading to a child every day and being sensitive to a child's development were significant predictors of math and reading readiness outcomes."

Nuts and bolts

The conclusions are based on analysis of national data collected between 2001 and 2007 that followed 7,000 kids from their birth to 5 years of age. Mothers were assessed as they interacted with their children, including some videotaping. Home conditions were also noted, among other things. In all, the original researchers gathered a data set containing a great deal of information that different researchers could analyze to answer the questions that interested them.

Forste is an expert on breastfeeding and Gibbs knows about cognitive outcomes, so they combined their areas of expertise to answer one of the persistent questions about children and breastfeeding: There's an association between breastfeeding and a young child's readiness for school, but is it the cause of the readiness?

The answer, they concluded, is no.

Videos were taken of moms who were given a bag that contained either a set of toy dishes or a book. They videotaped as they accomplished a 10-minute task with their 2-year-olds, Gibbs said. But the researchers weren't really interested in whether they completed the job. They were noting, instead, interaction details like whether mom turned the page and kept reading even though the child had a finger on a spot and seemed to want to linger. Moms who were good at picking up cues did things like stop and talk about that page or ask the child a question. The responsive, supportive moms reacted to gestures and expressions and that turned out to be very important to cognitive development.

Why it matters

The finding is "important enough that if I were going to, as a policymaker, structure a program to promote full readiness for school ... I would put my money on trying to encourage reading, which any caregiver can do, and helping (parents) learn how to respond to their children," said Forste. "There are plenty of reasons to promote breastfeeding, but not this."

In the study, they wrote that "although breastfeeding has important benefits in other settings, the encouragement of breastfeeding to promote school readiness does not appear to be a key intervention point. Promoting parenting behaviors that improve child cognitive development may be a more effective and direct strategy for practitioners to adopt, especially for disadvantaged children."

A BYU news release pointed out that child development expert Sandra Jacobson from Wayne State University School of Medicine praised the study in one of the journal's editorials. She emphasized that children in the study who were breastfed for at least six months did better than others on reading assessments because they also "experienced the most optimal parenting practices."

That's why they were reading-ready at 4 years, she said.

The same challenges that prevent some women from breastfeeding also prevent the other activities that boost cognitive development, Forste said. They include not being aware of the research showing what's needed, but also lack of time or resources to accomplish them. The good news is that it doesn't have to be mom who provides the extra boost. Dad or someone else can read to the baby every day and other people can also respond to a baby's emotional needs.

As for breastfeeding, there are proven benefits, including studies that show children who are breastfed are less likely to become obese. The American Academy of Pediatrics has a list of health benefits that breastfeeding bestows on babies, including protective benefit against respiratory infections, ear infections, gastrointestinal diseases and allergies, including skin reactions like eczema, among others. The rate of sudden infant death syndrome is reduced by more than a third in breastfed babies, and there is a 15 percent to 30 percent reduction in adolescent and adult obesity, compared to those who were not breastfed.

Email:, Twitter: Loisco

1. MrMas
Tucson, AZ,
March 14, 2014

Thank you, thank you, thank you! When I first heard about the correlation between breast-fed babies and cognitive development, I said to myself "perhaps moms who breastfeed also do other things that help a child's development." Finally a study that discusses this.

Correlation does not imply causality!

2. Hey It's Me
Salt Lake City, UT,
March 14, 2014

I bottle fed both my kids and they both got good grades are college graduates. Both my kids have bottle fed their kids and they are extremely smart. What counts is the quality time you spend with your kids.

3. LovelyDeseret
Gilbert, AZ,
March 14, 2014

We need to decriminalize the breast so that breastfeeding becomes as welcome as drinking from a water fountain.

4. BlueberryMom
Evanston, WY,
March 14, 2014

Breastmilk has obvious benefits to the child: health, intelligence, etc. That doesn't mean that people can go around looking down on mothers who choose to bottle feed their babies. I agree with LovelyDeseret in decriminalizing breastfeeding though. You really wouldn't believe the glares and "talking-tos" a mother gets when she breastfeeds her baby in public.

I'm baffled by the judgement on both sides; some mothers really get up-in-arms over things that really aren't their choice. It's not my business whether some mother formula feeds--I don't know what all went into that decision. Just like it's not somebody else's business that I breastfeed my baby.

I agree that spending time with your kids has a tremendous impact upon their development, but I also believe that breastmilk plays a part in that, too.

Can we stop the MommyWars and just support each other?

5. UtahMaus
Orem, UT,
March 14, 2014

I thought the title was a bit off topic, since what it boils down to is that early interaction and early exposure to books was what was most valuable.

As it happens, for medical reasons, I was only able to breastfeed one of my three. I did, however, begin reading to all three of them very early on (I'm a big Jim Trelease fan!) All three were "reading-ready" at four. I haven't seen any significant developmental differences between the three, except that the two girls (one breastfed, one not) talked earlier than the boy (not breastfed), and the youngest (not breastfed) walked earlier than the other two.