Wasatch School District defends decision to edit yearbook photos

By Benjamin Wood, Deseret News

Published: Thu, May 29, 2014, 2:20 p.m. MDT

 Students at Wasatch High School are upset after finding their yearbook photos were edited to comply with the school's dress code. This combination photo of Shelby Baum shows the original photo on the left and the edited photo on the right.

Students at Wasatch High School are upset after finding their yearbook photos were edited to comply with the school's dress code. This combination photo of Shelby Baum shows the original photo on the left and the edited photo on the right.

(Shelby Baum (left), Wasatch High School Yearbook photo (right))

HEBER CITY — Wasatch School District officials are standing by a decision at Wasatch High School to edit yearbook photos of students determined to be in violation of the school's dress code.

In a prepared statement posted on the district's website, administrators said students were made aware of potential edits on the day their yearbook photos were taken. District officials claim that a 4-by-5 foot sign was posted reminding students that clothing such as tank tops and low-cut shirts were not allowed and could lead to their photos being corrected for publication.

"When the yearbook comes out in the spring, students are always excited to see their pictures and are concerned with how they look in the yearbook, so it is understandable that students in violation of the dress code could forget that they received warnings about inappropriate dress," the statement reads. "However, there is no question that all students were advised that photos may be edited if the student’s dress did not follow the dress code."

School and district officials have fielded complaints from a number of students, all female, who say their photos were edited without warning to cover shoulders and necklines and to obscure tattoos.

On Thursday, Wasatch School District Superintendent Terry Shoemaker declined to comment on the photos, instead directing questions to the district's official statement.

In that statement, the district acknowledges that the school's yearbook staff erred in applying the dress code policy inconsistently by altering the photos of some students while leaving other similarly dressed students unedited.

"Wasatch High School and Wasatch County School District are evaluating the practice of photo editing of pictures as it now stands and will make a determination on further use of the practice," the district statement reads.

But Bobbi Westergard, a mother of one of the students whose photo was edited, said she accompanied her children to the registration day when pictures were taken and doesn't remember any dress code notices.

"There wasn’t a sign," she said. "There’s wasn’t anything sent out ahead of time that said dress code enforced."

Westergard said she believes the photos that were edited suggest a possible issue of discrimination. She said she worries that photos were chosen not because of the student's dress but because of school cliques.

"There’s really not any rhyme or reason to why they chose the girls they chose to edit and who they left alone," she said.

Westergard's daughter Shelby Baum, a sophomore at Wasatch High School, said her photo was altered by adding a false black undershirt with a tight neckline that also covered up a tattoo on her collarbone that reads "I am enough the way I am."

Baum said she would have been more understanding of the dress code policy if she had been told she needed to change clothes at the time the photo was taken, or if the policy had been applied to every student.

"I feel like they’re trying to shame you of your body," she said. "I can honestly say I wasn’t showing anything that should have been covered."

On Wednesday, Shoemaker said the district has heard from parents in the past concerned about inappropriate dress in school yearbooks. He also reiterated that students were warned in the fall that photos would be edited if clothing was deemed to be immodest.

"We believe the rules are fairly clear, and yes we believe also … that we could have done a better job in enforcing it consistently," he said.

Contributing: Paul Nelson, Nkoyo Iyamba

Email: benwood@deseretnews.com, Twitter: bjaminwood

1. Say No to BO
Mapleton, UT,
May 29, 2014

Over at the other newspaper in town there is a feeding frenzy in the comments section.
Posters there allege that there is a secret plot by the LDS Church to impose outdated modesty standards in the public schools.
Then again, the LDS Church gets blamed for just about everything over there.

2. agb
Layton, UT,
May 29, 2014

Why stop with editing the neckline and the sleeves? Just superimpose a burqa over all the girls in the yearbook.

3. Schnee
Salt Lake City, UT,
May 29, 2014

Iran must be sharing their photoshop secrets (they'd edited Michelle Obama's clothing before for one).

4. cjb
Bountiful, UT,
May 29, 2014

The edited photo is more blurry. I guess that is part of the penalty?

5. Liberal Ted
Salt Lake City, UT,
May 29, 2014

The Trib commenters seem to have a severe case of paranoia. Everything that happens in their life that they perceive as being "bad" is only because of the "boogeyman" LDS church. For such a "progressive" audience of "intellectual thinkers" they seem to be going through a drought of comparing facts rather than paranoid opinions.

With that said. If the school had the sign up and explained to the students the dress code. Then the only error was not applying it consistently when the editing was done.

If nothing else, they're helping these students from being embarrassed in the future when the media, police, employers, children etc look at these pictures.

I suppose we can say the same thing about Marines and Military when their pictures are taken. All in modest uniforms. No smiles. Tattoos covered. You don't hear about them crying about their expression being covered up.

If they feel that it's that important, then they can take a pic of themselves and insert it in their yearbook.

Iguarantee in a year, you'll never look through it again until your child pulls it out. Sees you and laughs. Then ask why they can't get tattoo....