Quantcast
Monday, Dec. 22, 2014

5 stories the Russian media is telling about the MH17 disaster that you won't hear at home

Compiled by Bethan Owen, For the Deseret News

Published: Wed, July 23 11:18 p.m. MDT

 Russian President Vladimir Putin listens during a meeting in Samara, Russia, Monday, July 21, 2014. Putin has lambasted those who use the downing of a passenger jet in eastern Ukraine for \

Russian President Vladimir Putin listens during a meeting in Samara, Russia, Monday, July 21, 2014. Putin has lambasted those who use the downing of a passenger jet in eastern Ukraine for "mercenary objectives," the Kremlin said Monday. In a statement posted on the Kremlin website, Putin again lashed out at Ukraine for ongoing violence with pro-Russian rebels in the eastern part of the country.

(Alexei Nikolsky, Associated Press)

The global spotlight has fallen on Russia once again as the country fields blame for the Malaysian passenger plane that was shot down over Ukraine and the 298 people killed as a result, according to Associated Press.

Russia’s response to the disaster has left world leaders wanting, but in addition to the secrecy cast around the crash site, the Russian press has been reporting vastly different stories than its Western counterparts. Below are five Russian news stories that have raised eyebrows, and how closely they correspond to Western news sources.

1. The plane was full of corpses when it left Amsterdam

The Russian news site Vesti ran a story arguing that nobody was killed in the crash because everyone on the plane had been dead the whole time, blaming the Ukrainian government for the elaborate hoax. The site quotes militia commander Igor Shooters as saying that when found, the bodies had all been dead for several days, and that the plane had a suspicious amount of medical cargo on board. The site also commented on the “amazing” state of the passports found on board, which the author described as looking brand new.

The large amount of medical cargo was not the result of a staged accident but was due to the approximately 100 HIV/AIDS doctors and specialists who were on board and headed to a conference in Malaysia, according to RawStory.

“Where Girkin believes the Ukrainian government obtained nearly 300 corpses is unclear,” wrote RawStory author David Ferguson. “Let alone how officials managed to dress the bodies and provide them with passports and travel information.”

2. The actual target of the attack was President Putin

An anonymous source told Russia Today that the attack on the civilian aircraft might have been meant for Putin’s private jet.

“The contours of the aircrafts are similar, linear dimensions are also very similar, as for the coloring, at a quite remote distance they are almost identical," the source said.

Putin’s plane often takes a route similar to the path of the Malaysian flight, the site said, and would have been a prime target for Ukrainian rebels.

There may be some credence to this theory, according to International Business Times. Writer Vasudevan Sridharan stated that “Putin's plane was in a similar flight path coinciding with the crash as he was returning from the Brics summit in Brazil.”

However it ultimately seems unlikely, Sridharan concluded. Since the turmoil in Ukraine began, Putin has avoided flying over the country. Russia Today agreed, writing that “the president does not fly over the conflict-gripped neighboring country (of Ukraine).”

3. The downed flight is actually MH370, the Malaysian flight that disappeared over the Indian Ocean

MH370 was hijacked by Americans, who flew it to the military base “Diego Garcia,” according to Russian news blog News2. Months later, the Americans loaded the plane with corpses, forged the necessary documents, and staged the crash, using the plane that was supposed to have disappeared into the ocean. “In the necessary spot, (the plane) was blown up, without even using a surface-to-air missile. Instead the plane was packed with a bomb, just like the CIA did on 9/11,” the New Republic quoted the Russian site as saying.

No other major players seem to be giving this theory any credence, based on a report from the Financial Times stating that Malaysia and Australia, two of the countries most affected by both disasters, are actively pursuing both events.

"Search efforts for MH370 continue unaffected by recent developments," read an email from the Australian Joint Agency Coordination Center. "Finding Malaysian Flight MH370 is a high priority for the Australian government, as well as Malaysia, China and other countries involved in the search efforts."

4. It was a Ukrainian-owned missile that shot down the plane

The primary reason that so much blame is falling on Russia and Putin is because the world has reached the general consensus that, even if it was fired by Ukrainians, the missile that destroyed the plane was owned and provided by Russia. Recently, Russian defense officials promoted a video showing a Ukrainian anti-aircraft system in the streets of Ukraine at the right time and place to have attacked the plane, according to Vox.

However, this video was soon discredited, primarily by ordinary Internet users, Vox continued. Those who studied the video found several discrepancies, including a billboard that didn’t match the Russian military’s description, the existence of trolley lines where none exist in the actual cited city in Ukraine, and others.

5. The flight deviated from its set path and flew lower than it was supposed to just before the crash.

The pilot of the Malaysian flight dropped his altitude based on an order from ground control, according to the Russian Life News, making it a closer target for the ground-to-air missiles. The plane was also flying mysteriously off course. “Until July 17, pilots conducted every plane over eastern Ukraine much further south,” Life News reported.

This story can be confirmed, according to CBS News. Despite the plane having flown that exact route 14 times in two weeks, Thursday saw a different path. “The Boeing 777 went farther north than typical,” according to CBS. “It's unclear why.”

While not all of the Russian news stories are exaggerated — and other countries have had their share of conspiracy theories as well, including accusing Russia of trying to start World War III and blaming the Illuminati — their stories are inaccurate enough to be worrying, according to the New Republic’s Julia Ioffe.

These widely circulating stories aren’t “an innocent you-say-tomato moment; this is a very problematic development,” wrote Ioffe. “The propaganda apparatus, much like the rebels in eastern Ukraine, has rolled on and on, fed by inertia and paranoia, reproducing and magnifying itself with each newscast.”

If Russian citizens continue receiving vastly different news than their Western counterparts, Ioffe continued, there is potential for disastrous misunderstandings in the near future. As Russia continues to refuse responsibility for the event, tensions will rise.

“Obviously, the state over whose territory it happened bears responsibility for this terrible tragedy,” Putin said, as reported by Russia Today. “This tragedy would not have happened if there was peace on this land, if military action in the southeast of Ukraine had not been resumed.”

According to an NBC report, Russians approve of Putin at record high numbers (83 percent) even as Russia’s global image is slipping.

Bethan Owen is a writer for the Deseret News Moneywise and Opinion sections. Twitter: BethanO2

Related Stories
Recommended
1. GaryO
Virginia Beach, VA,
July 23, 2014

Russian media is dominated by Russian Right Wingers . . . Nationalists who make up stories and pass them around, and when they come back, they believe them.

Russian Right Wingers are not that much different from American Right Wingers.

Their Right-Wing-controlled media is roughly equivalent to FOX "NEWS" and Right Wing Radio here in his nation.

They all indulge in lies and rhetoric that reinforces their ridiculous prejudices and makes them feel good about themselves.

2. Howard Beal
Provo, UT,
July 23, 2014

Not any different than many of our media saying that the US Government planned 9/11. I suppose any media can say anything and not actually be held accountable for anything.

3. 4601
Salt Lake City, UT,
July 23, 2014

GaryO

That's a creative spin, even if it's paranoid and delusional.

4. Whittling Whistler
Lehi, UT,
July 24, 2014

I bet Obama believes all of them. Mainly because his Russian friends would never do anything like use missiles to kill people.......until after the election.
I heard it, Obama plainly put his foot down and said NOT UNTIL "after my election" then they'd "have more flexibility." So he knows they wouldn't do that.....oh wait...

5. JimInSLC
Salt Lake City, UT,
July 24, 2014

Here is one that needs to be added to the list: The video posted online blaming the rebels for this action had a time stamp that was before the plane was shot down. The implication is that the event was planned, and those posting the video knew about it. The video was removed after a number of sites began reporting this. But as any intelligent person knows, what is posted on the internet stays on the internet.

What has Russia got to gain in trying to start a war? They have the power in that region as it is, it owns and controls the gas that the EU and Ukraine are dependent upon.

Putin may be corrupt, but he does not have a monopoly on corruption. We seem to have a good deal of it as well in our own government.