End of an era: Huntsville bookshop closing, monastery not far behind

By Emilee Bench, Deseret News

Published: Sun, Aug. 17, 2014, 3:05 p.m. MDT

 Father Mary Patrick blesses the Fagen family in the gift shop at the Abbey of Our Lady of the Holy Trinity, a Trappist monastery, in Huntsville on Friday, Aug. 15, 2014. The gift shop will soon be closing its doors and the entire monastery will close within the next few years.

Father Mary Patrick blesses the Fagen family in the gift shop at the Abbey of Our Lady of the Holy Trinity, a Trappist monastery, in Huntsville on Friday, Aug. 15, 2014. The gift shop will soon be closing its doors and the entire monastery will close within the next few years.

(Laura Seitz, Deseret News)

HUNTSVILLE — Driving under a canopy of trees tucked between rolling fields, visitors wind their way to the Abbey of Our Lady of the Holy Trinity.

"Each time we turn down the drive here … you just come down from whatever level you're on to a place of peace, of comfort," Lothair Pendleton said.

Pendleton and his wife, Dorothy, have been coming to the Trappist monastery and bookshop and gift store to escape a bustling world for more than 40 years.

He is a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and she is Catholic. But the monastery is a spiritual refuge for both of them.

"There won't ever be any place like this," Dorothy Pendleton said as she looked around the bookshop, clutching a rubber bracelet.

Now all the items are discounted 50 percent to empty the store before it closes.

For the monks, many of whom have been at the monastery for more than 60 years, the daily tasks of running the store have become too difficult. And there are no new recruits coming to embrace the monastic lifestyle.

Father Leander Dosch runs the store, and said at one time the monks had a dairy and chickens. They farmed the land and sold their famous bread and honey.

Eventually, those features were all dropped. And the monastery itself isn't far behind.

"It's inevitable, you might say," Father Leander said. "We're facing the fact that the monastery's going to close in a couple of years."

With just 10 monks at the monastery, Father Leander said they were told by their superior, Father Brendan Freeman, not to accept any new candidates. Father Leander said the monks there weren't able to offer the necessary training.

"I was prepared for it," he said of the news.

But many within the monastery community, and even more outside, were not.

"It's just a peaceful and calming place," Shelly Fagen said. "It kind of helps you center yourself and remember what's important in the world."

She said she's not sure where she'll find that refuge when the monastery closes.

Her husband, Kelly, said it's a sign of the times.

"It's a faithless society in some ways," he said. "And with modern technology, I think that teenagers are more detached and don't really get the big picture."

Kelly Fagen has been coming to the Huntsville monastery since he was 10. Living in New Hampshire wasn't going to stop him from sharing a day at the monastery with his daughters Kelsey and Kiley.

As the girls roamed the store, picking up medallions and books to give to family members they soaked in the quiet, peaceful feeling on the property.

"When I came and saw kind of, how empty it was, it kind of put me down," Kelsey Fagen said. "Because it was a special place and it still is. And I felt like it's going out. And it shouldn't."

Her sister Kiley described it as serene, sobering and peaceful.

"It's a special experience and you wish it was continuing for the rest of (the) generations to come," she said.

Lothair and Dorothy Pendleton said there are many places they go to find spirituality, but the monastery in Huntsville is one that cannot be replaced.

Several pieces from the store adorn her home — each piece leaves the store with a special blessing.

"They mean a lot to me and they mean a lot to the people I give them to," she said.

But the importance of the place is not about the purchased goods.

"It's been a place to come and meditate and feel close to God," Dorothy Pendleton said, her eyes welling with tears. "And to come up here and know it's closing, it's really hard. This has just been a beautiful place."


1. Mr_Normal
utah, UT,
Aug. 17, 2014

I remember my friend from the monastery Brother Mark.
He was such a peaceful, humble man.
I hope the remaining monks are taken cafe of. ^_^

2. Anchovey
Provo, UT,
Aug. 17, 2014

I too visited this monastery on a couple of occasions and know colleagues who went there for the peace the place afforded from this beautiful, but crazy world. The kindest souls made bread and honey...but best of all, they were truly interested in their customers. May our Heavenly Father bless you, all!

3. John Charity Spring
Back Home in Davis County, UT,
Aug. 17, 2014

Shame on those who have driven this monastery out of Huntsville.

4. KWL
Bountiful, UT,
Aug. 18, 2014

Please, read the article. The monastery isn't being driven out. There are not enough monks young enough to maintain it. They currently do not even have the resources to train newcomers if they were to join.

5. aceroinox
Farmington, UT,
Aug. 18, 2014

@ John Charity Spring--
Perhaps you misunderstood: the monastery is not being driven out of Huntsville. The monastery is not attracting new monks. As a result, those few remaining (only 10) are too few and are not physically able to manage the workload of the income-producing activities which supported the monastery. I suppose you could say "shame" on young people who either don't feel or don't respond to the monastic calling, but it seems a stretch to accuse them of "driving this monastery out of Huntsville."

I am saddened that the monastery is on the way out. It is truly a place of refuge in a beautiful valley. We loved going there to buy honey and interacting with the brothers there. I hope they are found a peaceful home for their waning years.